In Thomas Mann's "Death in Venice" the reader is presented
with the story of a man who cannot find the delicate balance between his
emotions and his intellect. It is this delicate psychological balance that
the author wishes most to address. Through the protagonist of the story,
Gustav Aschenbach, we as the reader learn of the potentially deadly effects
of not being able to find this balance, of letting either one of these polarities
in our thought's overwhelm us. In the case of Aschenbach, it is his inability
to find this balance that leads his inevitable destruction
From the dream passage (pp 1604-1605) the reader gets an ideal of just how
unbalanced Aschenbach's mind really is. The dream is highly symbolic of
Aschenbach own insecurity regarding his behavior towards the child Tadzio.
By the time we arrive to the point of the dream in the text it has become
fairly obvious that Aschenbach has become compulsively obsessed with Tadzio.
Aschenbach begins to contemplate everything from the boys physical stature
to his illustrious behavior (which he often compares to that of various
Greek gods). The dream that Aschenbach has is his minds way of alerting
both him and the reader to the unbalanced state in Aschenbach mind.
In the dream we are presented with a grotesque image of people engaged in
a lewd acts of worshipping. Their descriptions as being "men with horns
over their brows" (p1604) is significant in that we are being presented
with an image of sinister depraved beings. In addition, we can affirm by
this image by the authors description of their behavior. The women "swing
blazing torches", "brandish naked daggers" and carry "snakes
with flickering tongues" (p 1604). The men are "beating a furious
tattoo on the drums" (p 1604) while the boys prod at goats and cling
to their horns "yelling with delight as the beast drag them along."
(p1604). It is this image of sinister depraved beings engaged in this heathen
type of behavior that the author uses to represent the inner conflict and
struggle that Aschenbach feels.
Towards the last of the dream we began to realize more fully that the behavior
exhibited by these sinister beings (which the author feels should obviously
be seen as a revolting sort of behavior) begins to entice and lure Aschenbach
("Was it not enticing him..." p 1605). The enticement that he
feels toward joining in on this tabooed behavior is symbolic of Aschenbach's
growing infatuation with Tadzio ("and his soul craved to join the round
dance of the gods" p 1605). In the end we find that Aschenbach cannot
find a balance with his emotional desires but in fact plunges himself in
to this ritualistic behavior ("But the dreamer was now with them and
in them" p1605). What's more we find out that Aschenbach has willingly
degenerated himself to the level of those sinister beings as the authors
quotes "And his very soul savored the lascivious delirium of annihilation."
(p 1605)
It is from this dream we are able to conclude that Aschenbach is unable
to find that delicate psychological balance. Even with all of his logical
prowess (from what we know about him in the beginning of the story) Aschenbach
is unable to find that balance between sensuous experiences (his complete
enamorment with Tadzio) and intellect (which tells him that his behavior
is completely inappropriate), a balance between unselfconscious feelings,
immorality and decadence (symbolized most vividly by the imagery in the
dream) and icy intellect and moral respectability (the realization
that that behavior is indeed tabooed). Being unable to find this balance
is what inevitable leads to Aschenbach death, for as the author puts it,
though there may be no immediate resolutions for these extreme polarities
in thought, if either overwhelms the other (as what happens when Aschenbach
gives in to his impulses in the dream) than tragedy must inevitably follow.